AI INFLUENCERS ARE EVERYWHERE
BUT AUTHENTICITY STILL RULES
AI-generated avatars are signing brand deals, earning thousands on TikTok, and racking up more followers than some of the creators who inspired them. For brands, the allure is obvious: efficient production, unlimited creative variations, and the ability to “scale” influence at the click of a button.
But efficiency is not the same as impact. When marketing to the New American Consumer, authenticity is currency.
To be clear, AI is not the enemy. It can accelerate production, generate endless A/B tests, and unlock insights from oceans of data. For overstretched marketing teams, that’s a dream. AI helps brands track performance, identify emerging creators, and even pilot new content formats at low risk.
But when it comes to influence, the human act of sparking trust, inspiring action, and building belonging, AI has limits. Algorithms can mimic voice and style, but culture isn’t just syntax. Culture is context. And context is lived, not coded.
CULTURE CAN'T BE AUTOMATED
Take a Cuban influencer in Miami who flips effortlessly between English and Spanish in a Reel, signaling to viewers that both worlds are hers. Or a Mexican-American beauty creator weaving her abuela’s remedies into a skincare tutorial. Or an Afro-Latino comedian whose punchlines land because they pull from stories only his community shares.
These aren’t just entertaining details. They are trust signals — moments that tell audiences “I see you, I am you, I get you.” They’re micro-connections that build credibility and loyalty.
AI can replicate aesthetics, but it cannot replicate lived experience. That’s why culture leads influence — and why human storytellers remain irreplaceable.
WHY MARKET-SPECIFIC, CULTURE-FIRST CAMPAIGNS MATTER
This is also where many brands miss the mark. They flatten “multicultural” into a single message, delivered the same way everywhere. But Miami ≠ Los Angeles ≠ Chicago. Treating culture as a commodity erases nuance — and erodes trust.
Market specificity doesn't just complement authenticity. It's the engine that makes human influence scalable.
-
Culture ≠ Commodity
Communities are not interchangeable. Market-specific campaigns let brands respect differences while staying true to a central identity.
-
Authenticity Scales Through Relevance
Bicultural audiences — especially younger Gen Z and Gen Alpha consumers — have sharp “authenticity radars.” They know if a campaign is speaking with them or at them. Market-level activations, from slang to local influencers, unlock trust equity that national creative alone cannot.
-
Commerce Happens in Context
Where discovery happens shapes where purchase happens. WhatsApp plays a commerce role in South Florida that it doesn’t in Texas. TikTok is surging with Mexican-American Gen Zs in California, while Instagram remains strong among Puerto Rican audiences in the Northeast. Market-specific planning ensures campaigns plug into real behaviors, not assumptions.
-
Flexibility Within a Framework
National guardrails keep a brand recognizable. Local tailoring makes it feel familiar, real, and lived-in. Both matter.
-
Performace Demands Precision
Market-level testing generates data on what hooks, tones, and offers actually convert. Those insights fuel ROI and prevent wasted spend.
THE FUTURE IS HUMAN + AI
The winning formula isn’t human vs. AI. It’s human + AI. Let machines do what they do best — streamline production, surface insights, optimize. But let people lead where it matters most: culture, connection, community.
Because in an era of deepfakes and misinformation, audiences are questioning what’s real. Trust is the ultimate differentiator. And trust is built through human experience, not code.
WHAT THIS MEANS FOR MARKETERS
The takeaway isn’t just about influencers — it’s about how brands approach multicultural marketing in an era of AI. Technology will keep reshaping the mechanics of marketing, from media targeting to creative production. But culture remains the force that gives campaigns meaning.
That’s why our focus is on The New American Consumer: an audience that is not defined by one culture, but by many. They are bilingual, bicultural, and profoundly omnicultural — navigating multiple identities every day. For them, culture isn’t a niche. It’s the norm.
Reaching this audience requires more than automation. It requires culture-first campaignsthat respect market nuances while scaling relevance across regions, languages, and lifestyles. It means showing up in ways that feel personal, whether that’s a TikTok challenge in LA, a WhatsApp activation in Miami, or an event sponsorship in Chicago.
AI can assist, but it can’t lead. Algorithms can find efficiencies, but only people grounded in culture can create belonging.
For marketers, the path forward is clear: pair precision with empathy. Let AI do the heavy lifting, butlet culture shape the story. Because authenticity isn’t just an ingredient in influence — it’s the strategy that drives growth.
